|
|
Research by members of Historic Ellensburg is gradually adding
substance to a chronology of events surrounding the old Northern Pacific Railroad
station in Ellensburg, Washington. A large portion of what follows was
culled from hours spent scanning microfilms of old newspaper accounts.
We will be adding to this historical sketch as research permits.
Credits for dates and quotes will be found either within the paragraph
structure, or at the end of the paragraph.
The story of the station is entwined with the story of the railroad.
In brief, the Northern Pacific Railroad was created by an Act of
Congress. The Act provided for a railroad from Lake Superior to Puget
Sound. It gave the railroad a, “Land Grant, (of), 47,000,000 acres”
and, “cancelled any land titles along the route that had been given to
the Indians”. The Act was signed into law by President Abraham Lincoln
on July 2, 1864. “Much of (the) route was planned to follow the the
route of the famed 1804-1806 Lewis and Clark expedition..”.
Burlington Northern History
Due to the Civil War and financing problems groundbreaking did not
occur until February 15, 1870. Work crews heading West from Thomsons
Junction, (approximately 30 miles Southwest of Duluth, Minnesota),
faced relatively flat land up to the Bridger Mountains of Montana. The
West side crews, (largely Chinese), were working East from Pasco
tunneling through the main divide of the rockies at Mullen Pass. The
two crews met on August 23, 1883 at Hell Gate Canyon about 55 miles
West of Helena, Montana. Work began on the last stretch from Pasco to
Seattle in 1884. “There was no particular problem from Pasco to the
town of Thrall just South of Ellensburg. Then started the hard work as
they went up the mountains”. Until the tunnel was completed at Stampede
Pass trains mounted the pass and decended the other side by means of
switchbacks; the engines pulling on one switchback then backing up on
the next until the top was reached then going down switch backs the
same way on the other side. On May 27, 1887 the timbering throughout
the Stampede Pass tunnel was completed, “and the first train rolled
through”. op. cit.
The reader will remember the Midwest terminus of the Northern Pacific
Railroad as Chicago, not Duluth. However, it was not until 1901that the
NP and the Great Northern jointly purchased the Chicago Burlington and
Quincy, providing the two lines with “direct access to Chicago..”.
The reader can download
more complete histories on the following websites: Local newspaper accounts at the turn of the 20th century suggest an
Ellensburg public at odds with the Northern Pacific Railroad. Business
people, through the Chamber of Commerce, were demanding, “fast Train”,
service. Local, “milk”’ train schedules simply did not meet the needs
of an up and coming business community. Others in town were ashamed of
the shabby old wood station at the foot of 4th. Avenue. It did not
reflect the new brick buildings emerging from the fire of July 4,
1889, nor the pride of townspeople, who had rebuilt the downtown
following the fire. That these two issues came to solutions in the
same year, 1910, is testimony not only to public pressure, but possibly
to the presence of another railroad building West.
The Chicago Milwaukee & St. Paul Railroad (“Milwaukee Road”) a very
successful regional line, began to shadow the Northern Pacific to Puget
Sound. Coming directly West from Lind, Washington through Ellensburg,
the Milwaukee Road cut approximately 100 miles off the distance between
Spokane and Seattle. Furthermore, the Milwaukee eventually added the
competitive edge of electric engines through the Rocky Mountains
between Avery, Idaho and Harlowton, Montana, and through the Cascade
Mountains between Othello and Seattle, Washington. ( Electrification
through the mountains is a story within itself. Interested readers are
provided the following websites: As the Milwaukee Road began to buy up right-of-way and lay track,
local newspaper accounts, (Evening Record), hinted at cooperative
outcomes between the two railroads. The Northern Pacific whose track
moved from Spokane south to Pasco, West to Yakima then North to
Ellensburg, would use the Milwaukee rails between Lind and Ellensburg
and the Milwaukee railroad would use the N.P. tracks between Lind and
Spokane. There were even comments that the two railroads might also
share the Northern Pacific station in Spokane.
The reality, however, was two railroads in head-to-head competition,
serving many of the same towns across the plains and through the
mountains. During the years 1908-10 the Northern Pacific hinted at
laying its own track between Lind, (or Ritzville), and Ellensburg even
sending closed mouth survey crews to Lind, Ritzville, and Ellensburg.
“We really don’t know what work is laid out for us said an engineer
today, but I’ve heard that a cut-off is to be built out of here,
(Ellensburg) someplace”, (Evening Record, 12/27/1909).
Whether the competition scenario is entirely responsible for a new
station and fast train service in Ellensburg, there is no doubt about
the changes in rail service after 1910. The citizens of Ellensburg did
their part. Third street was paved to its terminus at the new Northern
Pacific station, and B Street was extended North to the new Milwaukee
Station. Citizen action, whether in cooperation or confrontation was
testament, at the time, to the monopolistic importance of railroads.
Trains were the only fast movers of just about everything tangible;
including mail, and even small town athletic teams going to scheduled
games and returning the same day. Intangibles like business
efficiencies, engineering/product development, news, ideas, events,
interests, myths, stories, music and eventually films followed the
rails into the creative imagination. The railroad station became the
hub nationwide. It was a place of, “excitement and anticipation”,
observed one Ellensburg citizen.
The building of Ellensburg’s new depot was assured by N.P. officials
toward the end of 1908. The Evening Record of 12/28/1908, reported an
estimated cost of $52,000. There was some factional discussion around
town as to placement of the new station. Some favored tearing down the
old station at the foot of 4th Avenue and erecting a new one on that
site. Others, particularly those owning close by properties, wanted a
siting elsewhere. The newspaper paraphrased still others who believed
the station would go, “where the Northern Pacific wanted it to go.”
The 3rd Avenue site was eventually selected by the Railroad sometime
around mid year, 1909.
Construction began in 1909, but there were delays. Most publicized was
the flooding that occurred in November. The flood not only brought rail
schedules to a standstill in all of central Washington, but filled the
“basement excavation” of the new station with such a flow of water
that, “. . . two gasoline pumps with paddle lifts, working two shifts,
were unable to keep the water down. A large centrifugal pump (was)
installed (and) operated by a steam engine. The whole outfit was
brought . . . from Lewiston by John Halloran, the contractor in charge
of the station.” (Evening Record, 12/1/09) As scheduled railroad
traffic slowly returned, work on the station resumed. The first course
of bricks for the North end of the station was laid in late November as
flood waters receded.
“Finishing Work Done on Depot”; read the headline of an article in the
Evening Record of June 8, 1910. “Plasterers and Italians who are
putting the finishing touches to the interior of the Northern Pacific
depot hope to complete their work by the end of the month. A series of
unforeseen delays has held up work to some extent, but the depot will
be ready for the public early in August. The tiffany brick wainscoting
in the lunch room and waiting rooms and hall to baggage room is now
laid. The finishing coat of hard plaster has been spread by the gang
now at work and men are now setting ornamental plaster of Paris
moldings in the ceiling. The Mosaic floor has been laid in the dining
room, and is partly completed in the waiting rooms and corridors. The
upper floor of the building has been wired and plastered and windows
and floor is all that is needed to make the office rooms ready for
occupancy.”
The predicted August opening was apparently a bit optimistic. An
article in the Evening Record of October 2, 1910 noted a letter from
N.P. officials to the Ellensburg Chamber of Commerce stating that the
depot would open to the public on October 31. According to the
article, “Several prominent businessmen, when interviewed today,
expressed themselves as in favor of holding a big banquet on that night
and inviting prominent men from all over the state to be present. Let
us celebrate a new era in Ellensburg, said one businessman, celebrate
the improvements made, such as paving, new buildings and the like . . .
invite prominent publicity men from all over . . . advertise what
Ellensburg has accomplished during the past year. Make this a big
event.”
The celebration did occur, apparently arranged and promoted by the
Ellensburg Chamber of Commerce. “. . . the railroad company having
left this matter to Ellensburg people to decide” (Evening Record,
10/2/1910). The seeming lack of interest in being a major player in
such celebration may reflect arrogant posturing in an era when the
railroad was not only the most efficient overland method of
transportation, but the only rapid means of overland transportation.
However the new station was viewed by Northern Pacific moguls, it
became, “our station”. It was, “what Ellensburg has accomplished during
the past year”, in the minds of local citizens.
If 1910 was the heyday of passenger rail service in Ellensburg, the
dominance of this form of rapid transportation was coming to a close.
The Milwaukee Road’s Pacific division was never able to establish a
competitive position in spite of electrification through the mountains,
and careful attention to roadbed improvement and maintenance. It was
permitted to cease passenger service in 1961 and, “halt all service on
4,600 of 9,500 miles of track in February of 1980. One thousand and 11
miles of roadbed was abandoned in Washington State”, (Daily Record,
February 26, 1980). (The consolidation/abandonment of railroads is
portrayed schematically by the ;
Family Tree of North American Railroads.) But much more than the
overbuilding of railroads was the emergence of technologies that led to
the development of two other means of fast travel.
The automobile, looking less like a buggy, and becoming more
reliable, was capturing the public imagination. By 1909 adventuresome
local auto owners had made it over Snoqualmie Pass to Seattle in three
or four days. The New York to Seattle automobile race prompted the
Kittitas County Commissioners to have the road to the Pass, “in the
best possible order... when the racers pass through...in June...” (The
Evening Record, 1/19/09). The Commissioners were characteristically
cautious, “...no repairs would be commenced at the present time as the
rocks and other debris...the worst features...would again accumulate
before the racers arrived...”. op. cit.
Flying machines in 1909 were stick and wire, dangerous and unreliable;
mostly an attraction at fairgrounds. By the end of the next decade,
(1920), the evolution of travel to private automobile, and multi engine
aircraft was well underway. The internal combustion engine was becoming
increasingly efficient, reliable, and easily manufactured. Oil, and
its main derivative, gasoline, was conveniently and abundantly at hand.
In the decades following WW II the railroads were lobbying Congress to
allow them to drop their money losing passenger service. Congress
eventually acquiesced, and established AMTRAC in an effort to maintain
passenger rail service. The name AMTRAC is the blending of the words
‘American’ and ‘Track. (Amtrak information can be found on the web at
AMTRAC
).
AMTRAC began service nationally on May 1, 1971; the route through
Ellensburg on May 3rd. “Would you believe one minute early for the
first Amtrak passenger train to stop in Ellensburg”, So began a Daily
Record article about 15 months after the Supreme Court approved the
merger of the Northern Pacific, Great Northern, Burlington, Spokane
Portland & Seattle, and Pacific Coast Railroads, (the latter usually
referred to as the Frisco). The merged companies were now the
Burlington Northern, and the old N.P. Depot Ellensburg’s Amtrak
station. Passed into history, the Daily Record went on, was N.P.’s,
“North Coast Limited,..the Alaskan, and...the Mainstreeter”. Gone since
1961 the article concluded were, “The Milwaukee Road’s Olympian,
Columbian and Olympian Hiawatha passenger trains”. Within two
generations passenger trains, once the only means of rapid transit,
were replaced by auto and bus traffic on Interstate Highways. Airline
travel became the rapid means of long distance transit allowing all
regions of the country to be reached t in a matter of hours.
Congressional legislation recognized the continued need for passenger
rail service. However, in establishing AMTRAC, Congress failed to place
it within a general transportation budget that recognized taxpayer
support of critical infrastructure, (“House kills mass transit”, UPI
Story reported in the Daily Record for October 6, 1972). Congress, in
fact, demanded that AMTRAC reach parity between income and expense. It
has never happened, and the ensuing yearly political struggle over
congressional support of AMTRAC resulted in the abandonment of many
major AMTRAC services in the futile hope of reaching parity. The
Stampede pass route through Ellensburg was one such service.
“The last Amtrak train is pulling out of Ellensburg”, so began the
lead article in the Daily Record for October 26, 1981. “...the end of
AMTRAK brought to a close 95 years of passenger train service...” Other
comments seemed like voices from 1909-1910. “The train company planned
no ceremony to cap the end of its decade of service...the people of
Ellensburg conducted their own...’ ‘The Chamber of Commerce bought a
block of tickets...for the last trip...other residents brought the
total to some 70 to 80 Ellensburg residents...”. “The depot to stand
empty”, capped the headline.
Burlington Northern officials made one final statement regarding the
depot. It would be placed with railroad recognized realtors and sold to
private investors. In point of fact the Burlington Northern Railroad
was gradually shutting down the Stampede Route between Seattle and
Pasco. The process of public announcements began prior to the end of
AMTRAC service through Ellensburg, (Daily Record quoting UPI sources,
6/1/81).
The depot, now sitting empty, was being vandalized. Photos of depot
trashing accompanied by articles of possible demolition of the
structure began the first of August 1985, in the Ellensburg Daily
Record, and ran continuously through September 12th of that year. A BN
spokesman, “said that BN negotiated with several parties who planned to
turn the station into restaurants...shops, but all deals fell
through...”. At the same time the article included comments from a
local business man who had applied for a demolition permit and was in
the process of buying the depot from the railroad. He claimed “ no
definite plans for the area”, but would not clarify when asked why, “
he (was) seeking demolition”. The Ellensburg City Council was expected
to put the “three month review into effect”. They wanted to look at,
“... the (possibility) of other options”.
Public outcry was intense. “Nearly fifty people turned out”, for the
City Council meeting on Monday, August 19, 1985---”one from as far away
as Boise, Idaho”. “The vote to delay demolition was unanimous”, (Daily
Record article for August 20, 1985). The demolition threat evaporated
on August 27, 1985 when Mayor Larry Nickel received a letter from the
Burlington Northern Railroad indicating their withdrawal of, “ the
request for a demolition permit”.
Previous to the withdrawal of the demolition request by the BN, the
owners of the Ellensburg Daily Record, (August 21, 1985) had offered to
buy the depot. “Our only interest is in saving it...the newspaper would
buy the building then turn it over at cost---or possibly nothing---to a
developer or community organization which would restore it”. The
newspaper did send a “written offer” for the depot to, “BN officials”,
but had heard nothing from the railroad as late as October 18, 1985.
The BN made a public statement on October 19, (Daily Record),
suggesting that the railroad was working with “several” party's on the
sale of the depot. The Daily Record offer was apparently not in
consideration at any time.
The depot did change hands. A group of local businessmen calling
themselves, Iron Horse Properties, bought the station from Burlington
Northern for $63,000 in 1987. Jurgen and Julie Greib, vintners, leased
a portion of the depot for a wine business; Cascade Mountain Cellars.
How long the Greibs occupied the station is unknown. The property was
then sold to Roger and Linda Hoff for $75,000 in 1990. The Hoffs were
the owners who placed the depot on the National Register of Historic
Places, (August 13, 1991). The present owners, David and Karen Bean
purchased the property in December, 1991 for $105,000.
The last known lessees of the property, Kittitas County Action Council
Inc., a local nonprofit human services agency, vacated the building at
the end of August, 1998. It has been empty since that date, and is
deteriorating more rapidly with every departing year. (A National
Register copy: Northern Pacific Railway Passenger Depot, OMB No.
1024-0018, Can be obtained from the Office of Archaeology and Historic
Preservation,
111 21st. Ave. SW,MS: KL-11, Olympia WA 98504)
There is no casting of blame. The depot is a victim of history,
tidied up from time to time to serve an immediate purpose only to be
emptied again. Structural problems were treated cosmetically. One of
the administrators of the Kittitas County Action Council laughed when
he said, “The pigeons drove us out”. The birds had gained entrance
through broken attic windows and open eaves.
Whatever the arguments over care, disuse was more likely the major
cause of the deterioration. As cars, trucks, and buses took over more
local transport, and passenger train schedules were trimmed, the
railroads were less inclined to give stations the attentions they
needed. This became more apparent as the railroads began political
actions that eventually led to the dropping of passenger service
altogether. With the departure of AMTRAC the Ellensburg Depot like many
others became a ghost of the past. Yet, in spite of its history,
“...(it) retains remarkable integrity”, as the Hoff’s observed in their
application to get the station on the National Register of Historic
Places.
The integrity that the Hoff’s saw in the depot is also reflected in
Ellensburg’s historic downtown, a downtown that local citizens see as
the hub of the community. City governments responding to recent growth
established the area immediately to the West of the historic downtown
as a commercial II zone. The zoning will allow business expansion as
part and protector of the downtown hub. The railway and depot lie on
the western edge of the CCII zone, and many are beginning to see a
restored depot as the defining piece of historic architecture on the
West side of the downtown. With its adjoining pocket park it could
become a tourist attraction, a great place for planned events, home for
commercial or public service agencies, maybe a transportation center
once again.
Nationwide rejuvenation of distressed historic buildings or distressed
city areas has energized local economies rather than draining them.
Historic Ellensburg, the organization, recognized this, and in 1999
with the support of the Ellensburg City Council and the help of its
staffs, wrote an application for a TEA-21 grant of $260,000 for the
purchase and weatherization of the old depot. The City was written in
as the grantee. The grant was approved dependent on matching funds and
a 20 year lease of the railroad land on which the depot sits.
Historic Ellensburg raised the matching money, (mostly from local
citizens), between the spring of 1999 and the Fall of 2000. Ellensburg
City Staff efforts produced the 20 year lease from the Burlington
Northern & Santa Fe Railroad in 2001. Negotiations between the City of
Ellensburg, (the grantee), and David Bean, the current owner of the
depot , are now underway over the sale of the building.
As we mentioned at the beginning the foregoing is a history in broad
detail. We will be adding more about the railroads as well as the
depot. Drop in every now and then.
|